Fruit - Friend or Foe?
MY EXPERIENCES WITH FRUIT
At the early age of 16, my interest in nutrition was sparked by a
friend who remained at home, afraid to exert himself because he had
been diagnosed by a doctor as having a weak heart. For four years he
remained fearful of exerting himself, till one day he went to a
Naturopath, who put him on an exclusive orange juice diet for 10 days.
All chest discomfort vanished and the Naturopath told him he never had
a heart condition, and that his chest pains were due to gas pressure in
his stomach, pressing against he heart, caused by wrong food
combinations.
I asked him to ask his doctor for some names of doctors who wrote on the subject.
The names received were William Howard Hay in "Health via Food", Rasmus
Alsaker, and about 10 other names, which included John Henry Tilden. I
began to go to the main public library in New York on 42nd Street and
5th Avenue on a regular basis, spending 3 to 5 hours looking through
their marvelous book collection, with some books going back to the
1600's. I looked up every recommendation, started to collect copious
notes and began to change my eating habits drastically. I tested every
diet that sounded promising.
My first radical move was to go on an exclusive fresh orange juice diet
for 10 days. My skin rapidly became free of all blemishes and I felt
excellent. This intensified my desire for more and more knowledge. I
studied the orthodox nutritionists to begin with - Henry Sherman of
Columbia University, Rose, Von Bunge, the English doctors - Thompson
and many others. I gave up all junk foods and ate only whole foods for
about 3 years.
FASTING
Then at 19 years of age, inspired by Dr. John H. Tilden, I tried my
first water fast, living exclusively on water alone which I remained on
for 10 days, Needless to say, my sister who was 1 year older than me
thought I had lost my mind.
We were 4 children living together in our family - our parents were
deceased, my mother 3 years earlier, under the legal guardianship of
our uncle, who lived separately. My sister was 20, I 19, with one
brother 18 and the youngest 13. I was like a papa of our family, my
sister worked daily, my sister worked part-time as a musician and we
shared our meager earnings. My sister tried to dissuade me, but my
insistence, backed by my faith, prevailed.
The 10 day water fast was an unforgettable experience. Since I was
doing it with the only guidance from books, I was somewhat fearful at
first, which I kept secret, but soon saw rapid changes in my
appearance, which encouraged me to continue.
After this I became a lacto-ovo vegetarian, when I immediately received
an offer to work at a hotel at a summer resort for 10 weeks. Most
interesting changes occurred in me physically and mentally on this diet
following the fast. I soon developed a sense of smell like a
bloodhound. I could tell what diseases people had just by the
radiations given off by their bodies. My psychic abilities suddenly
blossomed and I frequently picked up their thoughts, without trying to.
My life flowed so smoothly that I was like an expanded consciousness,
emotionally very calm, hardly aware of my body, which functioned
effortlessly.
After I experimented with diet changes after 2 months, adding bread and
some meat to my diet, I began to notice emotional changes and desires
entering my consciousness and the sudden loss of my super-sensitive
sense of smell. I felt as if I had fallen from the Garden of Eden, and
longed to return to this wonderful tranquility I had lost. I knew that
in the years to come I would be impelled further and further onward, in
an adventure as fascinating as Ulysses' travels were to him.
Read more about this fast with Q&A about water fasting - in "My first water fast".
FRUIT DIET
Years later, as many nutritionists of that time, I fell under the
spell of Arnold Ehret. His beautiful, alert expression in his
photograph of his "Mucusless Duet Healing System", was very
inspirational to me. He stated that all diseases were caused by mucus
produced by the unnatural food eaten, and that the best and most
perfect food was fruit, along with some green leafy vegetables, and
that man could reach perfection on such food alone. Thus began my
experiments with "Fruitarianism".
At intervals I went on long juice programs - some 10 days, other 20
days, several times each year. At one point, after living on grapefruit
juice alone for more than 2 weeks (occasionally canned and unsweetened)
I noticed my gums began to bleed and swell, and when I got to about the
18th day, my teeth began to loosen in my gums. This began to alarm me,
so I discontinued these juices.
Years later, while working as a musician in Ashbury Park, New Jersey, I
went on a 70 day fresh orange juice diet with no other foods. I lost
about 1/2 lb a day until the 20th day when my weight remained almost
stationary, losing only ounces over several weeks. I chewed on about 1
dozen oranges each meal and spitting the pulp out. I craved vegetables
but refused to eat them, believing in Arnold Ehret's insistence that
fruit was a perfect food - the Garden of Eden diet intended for man's
highest spiritual evolution.
Following this period, I later lived for 1 year on a 100% raw unfired
diet of fruits, nuts and vegetables alone. My weight was maintained and
I ate large amounts of fruit, feeling fine throughout. Years later, I
went on another 100% raw food diet, this time for 2 years, consisting
of fruits, nuts, vegetables, and 1/2 to 1 avocado almost daily.
Strangely, even though I wanted to lose weight, I couldn't, even though
I had been fasting on water alone for 2 1/2 consecutive days every
week. After the first day of each fast, I would lose 3 to 4 lbs, and
after the second day about 1 1/2 to 2 lbs. Then after 2 1/2 days when
I'd eat, I'd gain all the weight back within 3 to 4 days. For weeks and
months, my weight remained the same basically, even with all the
fasting.
Note: at one time I fasted every other day on water alone for almost 2
1/2 years, living on mostly raw, uncooked food on eating days, and felt
great throughout. I continued fasting 2 1/2 days a week, every week,
and maintained this habit for over 40 years, still continuing it to
this day. I looked forward to these fast days since they were my most
productive days - no distractions with eating, could sleep as much as I
wanted, enjoyed reading, studying and thinking even on philosophical
subjects.
FRUIT AND TEETH
When I was in my late 20's, I had the good fortune to meet a Naturopath
and Chiropractic doctor, a great leader and teacher in the field of
Natural Hygiene, Dr. Christopher Gian-Cursio, who introduced me to a
new wonderful world of balanced nutrition, which I went into deeply,
with the intention of becoming a practitioner some day.
He told me about his experiences while following Arnold Ehret, which
led to deficiencies in his diet. He once went on a grape cure,
recommended by Johanna Brandt. He lived on nothing but grapes, cases of
them for about 35 days. He ate pounds of them at each meal. By the 32nd
day, his gum was bleeding, and his teeth loosened in their sockets. He
said that one of his teeth fell out of his mouth. He exclaimed, "My
God, I am detoxicating my teeth."
At that point he knew that something was terribly wrong with the fruit
diet. It wasn't until later, when he read a booklet by a famous British
nutritionist entitled "Fruit, It's Use and Misuse". He said it was the
best book he ever read on fruit. I later read his book, but don't
recall his name. This doctor stated that according to the theory of
nutrition, fruit was alkaline in it's ash effect after digestion and
was good for you. But, after what he observed in many people, he came
to the conclusion that the alkaline ash present after digestion was due
to the fruit acids leeching out the minerals from the body to
neutralize the acids in the fruit. The body was not gaining in mineral content, but was losing the minerals from the bones, teeth and body instead.
The theory was based on a faulty interpretation of what actually
happened. This clearly explained what had happened to me on my
citric-acid fruit-juice diet. This also explained what had happened to
Dr. Cursio on his grape diet, rich in malic acid. This explained what
had happened to many people who went on acid fruit diets. I remember
when I was in a hotel in New York working with an orchestra, when
several of my teeth had loosened up, and one abcessed tooth caused my
face to swell greatly. Not wanting to quit the job, I began an
immediate fast on water alone, a method I had always used in
emergencies, whenever I was in pain. In a few days, the swelling and
pain subsided and was completely gone by the 10th day and 2 days later
I felt something in my mouth. I took it out and it was a molar tooth
with a big hole through it. My body had ejected the dead tooth - first
by producing an inflammation in my jawbone, followed by the loosening
and discard of the dead tooth. The same thing happened to me at another
time in my life when my body discarded another dead tooth the same way.
When I told the story to 2 dentists, they said they never heard of this
before. When my jawbone receded from the tooth, due to the loss of
minerals from the acid in the fruit, I years later lost 2 healthy teeth
due to the jawbone receding off the teeth.
A surgeon dentist who was a Natural Hygienist and later became my
dentist, in Rockaway Beach, Moe Leichter, told me that the worst
recession of the gums and loss of teeth he saw in patients were in
vegetarians and Natural Hygienists who lived mostly on fruit. He said
that their teeth were ridged, soft in some, and lacking in calcium. He
believed it was best to avoid heavy use of acid fruit.
Dr. Curio eventually recommended the use of only sub-acid fruits, low
in acids, like pears, golden delicious apples, and non-acid fruits like
melons, is the best of the fruits. My two favorite fruits, honey dews
and green Kadota figs were problematic to me. I found that the green
figs in excess (over 1/2 lb), would occasionally cause my mouth and
tongue to burn. After rinsing my mouth, my tongue was red, and I'd get
occasional blisters on my lips. Honey dews, in I ate the whole melon,
would cause my mouth and tongue to burn. When I rinsed my mouth the
water was pink and sometimes bloody from the acid irritation.
I remember when I was in my teens, I would go down around Hudson Street
in lower Manhattan to an animal importing house, owned by Henry
Trefflech. He'd have hundred of Rhesus monkeys who were fed heavily on
grain and some would develop bloody dysentery causing death in a few
days. He would sell me these for $5 and laughingly expecting them to
die. I would take them home, put them on a water fast and within a few
days the dysentery would stop and they'd be well. Then I'd try
different diets on them to gain experience, and when they reached good
health I'd sell or give them to ape shops and look for more sick
monkeys. I was somewhat annoyed to see them bite into expensive figs,
eat the soft sweet center and seeds, and throw away the whole outside
(the acid part). They never ate the skins or unripe part of fruit. This
caused me to discard anything I couldn't chew down, and kept that
practice going the rest of my life.
My fruitarian diet experiences, the problems I saw with fruitarians who
believed that fruit was God's gift to mankind, the dentist's years of
experience, led me to live mostly on melons, especially watermelon.
I had always been a great lover of fruits, especially melons, which I
ate liberally, considering it a natural food. My diet at that time had
been mostly raw consisting of salads (whole and blended), large amounts
of fruits, some nuts, seeds, fish, sea food and occasional chicken. I
had lived on a 1 meal a day plan for more than 35 years. I ate only at
night after a days work, having nothing but water at all times. I had
developed the habit of eating slowly, chewing all food well.
Almost always I felt wonderful, and having an empty stomach most of the
day allowed me to have all my energy easily available for mental and
physical work. The only problem that resulted from living on 1 meal a
day was that I wound up, after years, eating almost the amount of food
in that one meal that consisted of a total of 3 moderate-sized meals in
bulk. Since I always ate foods in the correct sequence (the most liquid
first, and the most solid last, as well as in the right combinations),
I had no difficulty digesting my meals even though the weight of that
one daily meal added up to several pounds, frequently over 3 lbs. With
occasional interruptions of telephone calls lasting 20 minutes or so,
the time I spent eating that one daily meal added up to an average 3 to
4 hours or more at night. The largeness of the many-coursed meal
provided my body with enough nutrition to satisfy all my needs for the
remaining 20 hours that I ate nothing, and I was never hungry the rest
of the time. By the following evening, my food was thoroughly digested,
with all senses alert and a keen appetite always present.
It was a wonderful lifestyle, living with energy truly available at all
times for even the most demanding mental or physical work, due to an
empty, peaceful stomach. Most people, even doctors, are not aware of
the fact that the greatest expenditure of energy in the body occurs in
the digestion of food. Most of our energy is lost in the digestive
process, so that even an extra slice of bread, eaten beyond the body's
need for food, can account for 3 to 4 hours of energy used up in manual
labor, such as shoveling snow. When not eating breakfast or lunch, this
energy becomes available for even the most difficult and prolonged
mental concentration, even exceptional sex ability, and when not used,
provides a feeling of exhilaration of mind and body which lasts all
day, every day, with rare exceptions. The only time I felt tired was
after eating when I enjoyed relaxation or sleep.
FRUIT AND SLEEP
At one time, in studying the harmful effect of excess carbohydrates
and its connection to almost all diseases, even though I had previously
considered fresh fruit as a natural and healthy food, I experimented
with eliminating it totally from my diet for several weeks. I wanted to
find out if the sugar in fruit could be harmful, even though fruit was
rich in nutrients, calories, minerals, etc. and highly recommended by
most nutritionists and doctors.
At that time I found that I felt alright if I could get at least 8
hours sleep, but then, I felt better with 9 hours, and even better with
10 hours sleep, which I attributed to my advancing age. I received a
call from a herbalist who was interested in old rare Natural Hygiene
books and all books on health. He visited me and we spent almost 8
hours each day for about 5 days, wherein he chose books and we
negotiated prices on each. He purchased half of my library, spending
thousands of dollars on these books. Having very little time left to
eat, I decided to omit all fruit from my diet and live only on salads,
proteins and some fat in one moderate meal. The next day he came early
when I had only slept 3 hours.
Usually, if I slept less than 5 hours any night, the next day I would
feel fatigued after a few hours. When driving I would get sleepy
occasionally and had to be careful to not doze off and when difficult
to keep awake, I would put the car to a side and rest my eyes and try
to doze for even a few minutes.
I was very surprised to find that I was not tired at all, but full of
energy as though I had 9 or 10 hours sleep. This continued for 5 days
of book sales, even though many hours were spent daily on boring
negotiations on many single books.
I stayed on this diet of no fruit at all for about 3 weeks, finding
that I felt good as long as I would get at least 5 hours sleep a night
on the average.
Then after the 3 weeks I decided to go back to eating fruit again to
determine the difference in how I felt. As soon as I added fruit to the
diet, I found that I needed a lot more a sleep that same night,
sometimes as much as 12 hours if I ate a lot of fruit. I discussed this
with Dr. Aajonus Vonderplanitz, a nutritionist in California, and he
said that he also needed a lot more sleep after eating fruit. He gained
weight quickly from fruit and any cooked food. This had been my
experience. The explanation was that the sugar in fruit, even though
considered "natural", retained fluid in the body just as salt did.
Since sugar in excess in the blood can be considered dangerous, the
body keeps it well diluted in fluid as a safety measure.
I recalled days in the past when I had eaten large amounts of
watermelon in the late afternoon. That night, 8 hours later I was
awakened in my sleep sometimes 8 to 10 times during this night to
urinate. I began to avoid these binges due to this sleep disturbance.
FRUIT AND MODERN RESEARCH
Even so-called "natural" fruit sugar can aggravate "candida"
conditions and it can be dangerous in diabetes, so we know that fruit
has to be controlled in its consumption. Authorities are coming more
and more to the conclusion that excess carbohydrate in the diet, sugars
and starches which quickly convert to glucose are responsible for the
cause of more than 80% of the most severe diseases - heart disease,
blood vessel diseases, and cancer among a long list. There is no
condition which is not affected adversely by an excess of sugar in the
blood.
Dr. Richard Bernstein, recommended highly by Drs. Eades, was a type 1
diabetic, who was deteriorating rapidly in vision, legs were losing
sensation, along with other very serious problems. He began to
experiment on his diet in an attempt to create a stable blood sugar
which remained in a normal range at all times, even after meals. After
years he succeeded only after eliminating all fruit from his diet
(appr. 25 years ago). And by limiting his consumption of vegetables
(which contain only 1 gram of carbs per ounce) to 1 cup of tossed salad
at the beginning of 3 meals a day, which included oil and a little
vinegar or lemon. Known as perhaps the world's greatest authority on
diabetes, he restricted his carbohydrates to a total of 14 grams a day
of salad (or cooked starchless vegetables), stabilized his blood sugar
at all times and became a super-athlete in his 60's, an anaerobic
athlete comparable to the world's great athletes.
We know that even if no carbohydrates at all are eaten, the body can
convert protein to carbohydrates needed by the brain and special organs
(viz. - the Eskimos and some tribes that live exclusively on meat).
When I stopped eating fruit, - tomatoes, cucumbers and succulent
vegetables became fruit for me, and I began to taste the sugar in
vegetables. After a few weeks I rarely thought about fruit and enjoyed
a life of great calmness and tranquility, free from the fluctuations in
emotions and moods that consistently follow sugar and fruit lovers.
Another bonus was control of weight at all times, which for me was a
god-send.
In the 1990's and beyond, nutritional authorities began to write on the
dangers of high sugar, and later, a high carbohydrate diet. Carlton
Fredericks included natural fruit and its sugar as a culprit in
hyperglycemia, then hypoglycemia. E.M. Abramson, in " Body, Mind and
Sugar" spoke of the dangers of excessive glucose in the blood. William
Duffy with "Sugar Blues" was another writer. Of the recent writers
there were Dr. Robert Atkins, Drs. Mary and Michael Eades, Dr. Richard
Bernstein, etc. All of these considered the sugar found in fruit to be
a cause of the rapid rise in insulin secretion by the pancreas. When
excessive it produced hyperglycemia (excessive sugar in the blood).
This was soon followed by hypoglycemia (a marked lowering of the normal
blood sugar).
Excessive insulin secretion to handle the excessive sugar in the blood
leads to cellular insulin resistance, over-excitation of the pancreas,
then the adrenal glands, the thyroid gland and a host of complications.
For a full presentation of the dangers of excessive blood sugar, I
recommend "Protein Power" by Michael and Mary Eades.
Dr. Cursio over the years was decreasing the amount of fruit he allowed
his patients - from 12 oz at a meal, he lowered it to 8 oz. maximum.
TESTING ALL DIETS ON MICE
In 1990, after many years of reading, study and research of books
written by doctors and nutritional authorities, each recommending their
particular diet as the best of all, I decided that - since it could
take many years to test each individual diet, and many lifetimes to
test all of the diets - the best way to reach a reasonably scientific
conclusion to this question was to do my own testing of all the
possible diets on mice. Since 1 day for a mouse is equivalent to
approximately 30 days for a human, by running several different diets
on hundreds of mice, I could in a few years get the final answers on
all possible diets.
I began this project testing raw vegetarian/vegan diets, cooked,
lacto-vegetarian, ovo-vegetarian, lacto-ovo-vegetarian, the addition of
fish, fowl, meat etc. both raw and cooked. After awhile, I tested the
fruitarian diet. In a cage of 40 white mice I put all kinds of fruit.
They ate some but were still hungry, so I added fresh corn-on-the-cob
and avocado. All seemed well until the 3rd day, when I went to the
cage, I saw 8 dead bodies with the heads missing and parts of some
bodies eaten. I was shocked at the carnage. This was equivalent to
severe deficiencies occurring to humans after 2 months on this type of
diet. I immediately put the cage on a full diet including raw milk
cheese, cooked food, grains, etc. to stop the deaths. Even with the
diet change, other deaths followed for about 4 more days before it
ended and conditions returned to normal.
Two years later, I repeated this diet again on this same cage, which
had since recovered their health, and the same thing happened. On the
3rd day of this very liberal fruitarian diet which included
corn-on-the-cob and avocados, I found 7 dead bodies cannibalized with
their heads missing, I immediately stopped this "fruitarian" diet,
which was the next direction of all of the 15 different diets + an
additional 50 other related follow-up diets which I tested. From that
time forward I have cautioned all prospective aspiring fruitarians to
avoid this dangerously deficient diet, since I had proven it on living
creatures close enough to man to have some relative validity.
Dr. Stanley Bass
10-2004
http://drbass.com/aboutfruit.html
|